Decision Quality
The first problem you see is rarely the one you need to solve
Most consequential decisions in founder-led businesses are made against the most visible explanation, not the most likely one.
Harsh Bhushan · 12 January 2026 · 6 min read
A number moves. Enquiries fall, conversion softens, delivery slips, a good person leaves. Within a day, the business has an explanation. Within a week, that explanation has become the plan.
The explanation is rarely fabricated. It is usually the one most available to whoever noticed the movement first — which makes it a description of internal attention rather than of the business.
Four things that are routinely collapsed into one
- The observation: what actually changed, stated without interpretation.
- The interpretation: what we believe that change means.
- The hypothesis: the mechanism that would produce that change if our interpretation is right.
- The requirement: what the business would need in order to be different.
When these four are collapsed, the organization commits resources to an interpretation while believing it has committed them to a fact. The cost is not only the failed intervention. It is that the failure is later cited as evidence that the approach does not work here.
A practical discipline
Before authorizing a response, write the two most credible competing explanations and the single piece of evidence that would eliminate one of them. If no such evidence exists or can be obtained cheaply, the decision is a bet — which is sometimes correct, but should be named as one.