A recognizable situation

Strategy is not translating into repeatable performance

The direction has been decided. It has been communicated more than once. Tools have been bought, processes written, and reviews scheduled.

Six months later, the parts of the strategy that required new judgment are the parts that did not happen — while the parts that resembled existing habits did.

01

Why this matters commercially

Repeated non-translation teaches the organization that stated priorities are provisional. The next strategic commitment is then met with rational, quiet scepticism.

Leadership responds with more communication or more monitoring, both of which raise cost without changing the conditions that stopped the work.

02

Why the visible explanation may be incomplete

The visible explanation is poor execution or insufficient buy-in. Often the more accurate reading is that the strategy specified an outcome without specifying the mechanism — the change in who decides what, on what evidence, reviewed by whom.

03

Explanations that remain plausible

  • The strategy named outcomes, not mechanisms

    Targets were set without describing the operating change required to produce them.

  • Systems were installed without judgment travelling with them

    The process exists; the reasoning behind it does not, so people follow it literally or abandon it under pressure.

  • The new work competes with unchanged priorities

    Nothing was stopped, so the additional intent is absorbed by whoever has least resistance to absorbing it.

  • Ownership sits with a group rather than a person

    Shared ownership of a consequential change usually resolves to no ownership at the first conflict.

  • There is no evidence loop

    Nobody agreed in advance what would indicate the change is working, so the change is neither corrected nor confirmed.

04

Questions that would distinguish between them

  1. 01For the last significant strategic commitment: what operating decision was supposed to change, and did it?
  2. 02What was stopped to make room for it?
  3. 03Who owns it individually, and what authority came with that ownership?
  4. 04What evidence would have told you within 30 days that it was not taking hold?

05

Where the work may sit

Architecture

Translating intent into a mechanism: the decisions, owners, thresholds and review points through which the strategy becomes operational.

Capability

Developing the judgment the new mechanism assumes, so it can survive situations the process did not anticipate.

Leadership

Reinforcing the change through attention and review, and being visible about what will no longer be acceptable.

06

What cannot be concluded without evidence

Whether the failure sits in the strategy, the mechanism or the reinforcement is an empirical question. It cannot be answered from a description of the symptom.